In a rapidly evolving energy landscape, the latest insights from McKinsey’s Global Energy Perspective 2025 paint a sobering picture for those banking on a swift transition to renewables. Despite aggressive global efforts to curb emissions, fossil fuels are projected to retain a dominant role in the world’s energy mix well beyond 2050, accounting for 41-55% of global energy consumption by mid-century—down from today’s 64%, but far higher than earlier optimistic forecasts. This persistence challenges the narrative of an imminent renewable takeover and has profound implications for investors navigating volatile markets.
As we delve into the McKinsey report, we’ll explore why fossil fuels continue to offer attractive returns, why renewables like wind, solar, and hydrogen are struggling to deliver for investors, and whether natural gas can offset the anticipated dip in oil prices.
McKinsey’s Outlook: Fossil Fuels’ Enduring Grip on Global Energy
McKinsey’s analysis, released in October 2025, models multiple scenarios for the energy transition, from a “slow evolution” baseline to an “accelerated momentum” pathway with strong policy support and tech breakthroughs. Across these, fossil fuels—oil, natural gas, and coal—remain integral due to entrenched infrastructure, economic advantages, and reliability. Demand for fossil fuels is expected to plateau between 2030 and 2035 in most scenarios, but not decline sharply until after 2050, driven by growth in emerging markets and sectors like heavy industry and aviation where alternatives lag.Key reasons for this dominance include:Infrastructure Lock-In: Trillions in existing assets, such as pipelines and refineries, create barriers to rapid phase-outs.
Got Questions on investing in oil and gas? Or do you have a Tax Burden in 2025?
Reliability Needs: Intermittent renewables require backup, often from natural gas, to maintain grid stability amid rising electricity demand from electrification and data centers.
Economic Factors: In many regions, fossil fuels remain cost-competitive without heavy subsidies, especially natural gas as a “bridge fuel.” The more LNG demand grows, it is questionable how long it will be a bridge fuel, but more like a staple.
Global energy demand is forecasted to rise 17% above 2019 levels by 2050, with electricity demand doubling, but renewables alone can’t fill the gap quickly enough. Renewables like wind and solar are set to grow, some people claim that potentially comprising 61-67% of the power mix by 2050, but their share in overall primary energy remains limited to 20-30% due to challenges in scaling for non-electric uses.
Hydrogen, touted as a game-changer, is unlikely to achieve wide adoption before 2040, contributing only 5-10% of final energy by 2050 in optimistic cases.This outlook underscores a multi-decade role for fossils, prompting investors to reassess portfolios amid geopolitical tensions and supply chain risks.
Why Fossil Fuels Are Delivering Strong Returns to Investors
Contrary to the push for divestment, fossil fuel companies have rewarded investors handsomely through dividends and share buybacks. In 2024 alone, the global oil and gas industry distributed nearly $213 billion in dividends and $136 billion in buybacks, reflecting robust cash flows from high commodity prices and operational efficiencies. While fossil fuel stocks returned just 5.72% in 2024—underperforming the S&P 500’s 25.02%—the sector’s focus on capital returns has made it a haven for income-seeking investors.Returns are bolstered by:High Margins and Cash Generation: Oil majors like ExxonMobil and Chevron have capitalized on prices averaging $80-90 per barrel in recent years, generating free cash flow yields of 8-10%.
Discipline in Capital Allocation: Post-pandemic, companies prioritized payouts over aggressive expansion, reducing debt and enhancing shareholder value.
Resilience to Transition Risks: In McKinsey’s view, fossil investments offer IRRs of 8-10% for new projects through 2040, particularly in natural gas, with lower stranded asset risks than feared.
As banks pull back from energy lending (down 25% in 2025), private equity and sovereign funds are stepping in, eyeing undervalued assets in a market where fossils still supply 86.7% of global demand.The Struggle for Returns in Wind, Solar, and HydrogenWhile clean energy investments hit $2.2 trillion in 2025—double that of fossils—the story for investor returns is far less rosy. Wind, solar, and hydrogen projects often face slim or negative margins due to structural challenges, leading to underwhelming stock performance and capital flight.
For wind and solar:Oversupply and Price Crashes
Solar panel prices plummeted 60% over the past decade, squeezing manufacturer profits and leading to a 13% drop in utility-scale financing in the first half of 2025. Onshore wind faces supply chain bottlenecks and higher interest rates, inflating capex and reducing IRRs to 10-15% at best, often lower without subsidies.
Grid Imbalances and Negative Pricing: Excess renewable generation causes spot market volatility, with negative prices eroding revenues—up to 20-30% losses in some European markets.
Policy Shifts: U.S. investments fell 36% in early 2025 amid regulatory uncertainty, redirecting capital to storage or other sectors. Renewable stocks, tracked by indices like ICLN, declined 10-15% in 2024, far worse than fossils.
For hydrogen:High Costs and Low Scalability: Green hydrogen production remains uneconomical, with IRRs of 6-9% initially, hampered by electrolysis costs and infrastructure needs. Venture capital fundraising dropped one-third in 2024, reflecting skepticism over viability.
Market Immaturity: Only 1% of hydrogen is low-carbon, with projects facing technical barriers like efficiency losses and supply chain gaps. Publicly traded hydrogen firms lost 20-40% in value in 2024, deterred by $75 billion in announced projects yielding minimal near-term returns.
These factors explain why many investors see renewables as high-risk, growth plays with delayed payoffs, rather than reliable income sources.Can Natural Gas Compensate for Lower Oil Prices?With Brent crude forecasted to average $62 per barrel in Q4 2025 and $52 in 2026 amid oversupply and slower demand growth, oil’s profitability may wane. However, natural gas emerges as a bright spot, potentially offsetting losses through surging demand and price upside.Demand Drivers: U.S. data centers alone could boost power demand 25% annually through 2030, with global AI-driven needs growing 17% yearly—much met by gas-fired plants. LNG exports and industrial use in Asia are also accelerating.
Price Forecasts: Henry Hub prices are projected at $3.42/MMBtu in 2025 and $3.94 in 2026, up from recent lows, with analysts eyeing $4.00 by Q4 2025. Colder weather and supply constraints have already pushed futures up 8% in October 2025.
Investment Angle: McKinsey sees natural gas as a transitional winner, with 10-12% IRRs for LNG projects, compensating for oil’s downturn in integrated portfolios.
In essence, natural gas’s flexibility and demand tailwinds position it as a hedge against oil volatility.
What Investors Should Look For
For those eyeing the energy sector:Diversify Across Fossils: Focus on integrated majors with strong balance sheets and natural gas exposure for steady dividends.
Selective Renewables: Target subsidized projects or storage tech for growth, but avoid overexposed wind/solar manufacturers.
Monitor Policies and Tech: Watch for breakthroughs in hydrogen or geothermal that could flip returns, but prioritize near-term cash flows from fossils.
Risk Management: Geopolitical events and carbon pricing could accelerate shifts—hedge with ESG-compliant fossils.
The alleged energy transition is underway, but fossils’ dominance past 2050 suggests a balanced approach will yield the best results. It seems to be more like an energy addition rather than a transition. As McKinsey notes, the path to net-zero requires $4-5 trillion annually post-2030, but for now, fossils remain the backbone—and the better bet for returns.
Got Questions on investing in oil and gas? Or do you have a Tax Burden in 2025?
Crude Oil, LNG, Jet Fuel price quote
ENB Top News
ENB
Energy Dashboard
ENB Podcast
ENB Substack
Be the first to comment